Sunday, January 29, 2023

About the Audience or For the Audience?

How does one define community? How does one articulate representation? How does one differentiate authenticity with inaccurate depictions? As a Muslim Indian-American, growing up with the screens of Hollywood, I have encountered my fair share of media representations far from accuracy. From Ravi in Jessie to Kamala in Ms. Marvel, the media ethnic groups have consumed has been feeding the public with entertaining content, but at the cost of a representation of reality. You and I may not realize it at first glance, but subliminal meanings in our favorite TV shows and movies often suggest rooted stereotypes and perpetuate harmful portrayals. 


Crazy Rich Asians. A comfort movie, right? What if I told you that the beautifully written and produced romcom was just mimicking an elite American society, hindering an authentic representation of Asians and their culture - a mirror of America at its highest level, emphasizing wealth and privilege to demonstrate white-Asian equivalence. But in the process of trying to depict rich Asians as the “right” Asians, they also assumed the characteristics of the “wrong” Asians. The film tried to overcompensate in debunking typical stereotypes, setting the Asian characters to the highest social status without regard for authenticity. And it was this lack of thoughtfulness where the representation Crazy Rich Asians illustrates can be criticized. I just ruined the movie for you, didn’t I? 


When analyzing a visual text in depth, whether it be a magazine cover or a movie, you will uncover stories that entail misrepresentation that aren’t outwardly apparent. Whether intentional or unintentional, any meaning suggesting a stereotyped role that crosses the screen will ultimately harm that community. And it is that intention that doesn’t translate, making the way it was discerned damaging, regardless of the initial intent. 


Ms. Marvel. 2022 and they finally got a representation of Muslims that was right! It took producers and writers long enough to include Muslims in a story that didn’t succumb to violent and false single stories. A female Pakistani protagonist, Kamala Khan, embracing her culture and religion, appreciating her family’s rich history, and being a superhero must have quenched the representation Muslims have been anticipating for so long! But when analyzing its scenes carefully and thoroughly, even this show proved to sustain society’s preconceived notions of negativity in Islam - the notion of the religion being correlated to rooted misogyny and sexism. While being a comparatively legitimate representation of Muslims and South Asians, it has some holes in its execution, supporting ideas that ultimately make the Muslim community vulnerable to negative consequences. You may be replaying the show in your head, trying to find where they went wrong. But this negative, subliminal portrayal was hidden in the shadows, lighting and expressions of the scene in the Mosque.

   When Kamala spoke while sitting in the women’s side of the Mosque, she was met with negative looks from the men, peering through the partition highlighting the shadows on her face. While the men sat in the open, well-lit section with big windows and no visual obstructions, this scene emphasized the darkness and shallowness captured through lighting and camera angles in the women’s section, implying a sense of inferiority and dejection. While Muslims in Mosques have been notoriously known for their system of separating the genders to protect modesty, this concept has been blurred by the idea that the religion hinders and devalues women in comparison to men, and Ms. Marvel just added fuel to the fire. 

So why do we keep seeing these cyclical trends and perpetuation of stereotypes in mainstream media? The issue lies where producers choose to feed their audience with what they want to see, rather than display concepts and stories that can be true. Society is more likely to be entertained and accept a story that holds notions they already believe, rather than being introduced to an idea that creates dissonance to their perceptions. So we continue to feed into this entertainment, consuming media that is selective, biased, and inaccurate. Honest representations continue to be obstructed with writers and producers cultivating a story that would be more understandable for an audience that isn’t the subject of the content. Trying to emphasize normalities in a way to make a point about a community to those who aren’t a part of it takes away from representing those people around their human qualities. It just becomes an exaggerated or inauthentic portrayal of lifestyle - a lifestyle that feeds into stereotypes we consume all the time. And you and I both are guilty of it. 


So next time you click on a show on Netflix or go see a movie at the theaters, I encourage you to be mindful of the details that create realistic representations and aspects that sustain stereotypes. I challenge you to pick up on the factors creators choose to put on the screen, and weigh them on your own moral compass. And I urge you to ponder about the complexities and simplicities of the representations put before you, examining the intentional or unintentional messages interpreted. These are things we forget to pay attention to in light of entertainment, but being cognizant of these elements will prove to be beneficial to you in your own mind and your own conscience. And you will become a more knowledgeable consumer of media everywhere. Trust. 



Want to read more on the misrepresentation portrayed in Ms. Marvel? Click here!

Perpetuating Harmful Stereotypes: Misogyny in Islam

Sunday, October 9, 2022

Language and Culture: Unintentionally Breaking Ties

 


    Personality, gender, and age. Culture, race, and values. Identity, confusion, and crisis. For first generation Americans like me, I think we can all come to the consensus that articulating a foundational identity is much more complex than a simple tag such as “Indian-American.” Society has chosen not to accept our diverse displays of identity, but the more pressing issue is that we have conformed to those definitions.

 

    My parents were born in India but I was born in a small town in New Jersey. My friend was born in the Philippines but moved to this town in Jersey before she turned one. There are so many of us that can fit in the same scenario when it comes to simply stating our background with the abundance of times we have been asked “so where are you from?” But when we respond with “oh right around here,” we get the follow up: “No I meant where are you really from.” In the country of “opportunity” and “diversity,” the United States has really come to lack giving immigrants a sense of belonging. From once encouraging immigrants to set foot onto this land, the now lack of language inclusivity this nation has established is louder than ever. We always relish on all of the favorable circumstances this country has given our parents, but it’s time to come to terms with the existing system that has protected and favored the English language, hindering the value of foreign languages and those who speak it.

    My parents moved to a country where being bilingual in the upper class was a sign of intelligence while being bilingual in the lower class was frowned upon. In Amitava Kumar’s essay, “Language,” he discusses a situation where a Hispanic mother was ordered to stop speaking Spanish with her five-year old daughter since she was a “full-blooded American.” She was told it was in her best interest to prioritize only English because the education system favors the language. Also in the article, “‘Stop measuring black kids with a white stick’: how to make school assessments fairer for all,” the authors articulated how “the assessment also privileges the monolingual student,” and us first-generation immigrants are reaping the repercussions of this establishment (Steele).


 

    But this English superiority doesn’t just exist here in the United States. Kumar also discussed how remnants of British imperialism have persisted into modern day India, and how those values have been rooted into Indian society. From valuing schools established by the British, to having a higher social status for studying in an English medium, a country that has hundreds and hundreds of rich, ethnic languages has conformed to believing English is still the superior tongue. But our parents who grew up in that mindset still lived in the atmosphere that fostered that full sense of culture, engaged in customs, traditions, and their heritage; something we do not have.


    Even though at home we are exposed to our rich culture and languages of our mother lands, in the building we spend at least 7 hours in 5 days a week, we are restricted to speaking solely English. And even though nothing is stopping us from valuing our mother tongue at home, speaking English this often for our entire lives has given us quite the lavish comfortability with it, and we have become so accustomed to English it seems that our mother tongues are slipping away. What the aunties and uncles call my “broken Gujarati” and “white-washed Hindi” is simply the consequence of the education system setting English at the highest standard of language, viewing every other speech less than sufficient. What is put into perspective through this is how easy it is for our culture to slip away in this country, so what is the fate of carrying our mother tongues and culture into generations to come?

    

    I so badly want to hold onto the languages that tie me back to my origins: my parents, my grandparents. The country that they grew up in, shed tears in, and made memories in. But I don’t have confidence in these languages to retain them and authentically pass them down to generations to come. And that’s scary. I do not have the skill to effectively communicate and hold lengthy conversations in my mother tongue as my ability in speaking these languages only goes as far as small talk when my grandma calls from India asking how I’m doing. “Mein theek hu, aap kaise ho,” translating to, “I am fine, how are you,” is one of the only repetitive phrases I am confident in. And over the years, I have gone from speaking only Hindi and Gujarati at home to a mix of both, and now finally to answering in English while my parents speak in either language. So thinking about whether I will be able to advance the ethnic tongue onto my children one day is frightening, and I know a lot of my peers struggle with the same thought. How do you confront these heavy thoughts, feelings, and emotions?




Works Cited

Steele, Carly, et al. “'Stop Measuring Black Kids with a White Stick': How to Make School 

        Assessments Fairer for All.” The Conversation, 12 Aug. 2022, 

        theconversation.com/stopmeasuring-black-kids-with-a-white-stick-how-to-make-school-

        assessments-fairer-for-all-180024.


Kumar, Amitava. “Language.” Critical Encounters with Texts, 2000, pp. 286-290.


About the Audience or For the Audience?

How does one define community? How does one articulate representation? How does one differentiate authenticity with inaccurate depictions? A...